TL;DR

• Pick CasePeer if you run a personal injury firm that needs PI-specific workflows like settlement negotiations, medical treatment tracking, and statute alerts out of the box.
• Pick MyCase if you’re a solo or small general-practice firm that wants lower entry pricing ($49/month, or $39 annual) and built-in billing and online payments.
• Core tradeoff: depth in PI-specific case management (CasePeer) versus breadth across practice areas with billing-first functionality at a lower price (MyCase).

Side by side

Dimension	CasePeer	MyCase
Founded	2015	2010
HQ	Los Angeles, CA	San Diego, CA
Target firm sizes	Small, mid	Solo, small
Practice areas	Personal injury	General
Starting price (monthly/seat)	$79	$49 ($39 annual)
Gated pricing	No	No
Integrations listed	0	0

Pricing

Both vendors publish three tiers publicly (neither is gated).

• Lowest tier. CasePeer’s Basic is $79/seat/month. MyCase’s Basic is $49/seat/month, or $39/seat/month billed annually, roughly half the CasePeer entry price. CasePeer Basic focuses on PI-specific features (settlement negotiations, medical treatment tracking, automated statute alerts, client trust tracking). MyCase Basic leans toward general practice essentials (time entry, billing and online payments, legal calendaring, basic financial reporting).
• Middle tier. CasePeer Pro is $119/seat/month and adds client intake management, 2-way texting, litigation event plans, 50+ reports, and 8am IQ legal AI / AI writing assistance. MyCase Pro is $99/seat/month ($89 annual) and adds 8am IQ, custom fields, unlimited 2-way texting, client intake management, unlimited eSignature, and advanced billing.
• Highest tier. CasePeer Advanced is $149/seat/month and includes API access, case grades, multi-office reporting, scheduled texts, and an intake investigator portal. MyCase Advanced is $119/seat/month ($109 annual) and adds MyCase Drive, full text search, 8am IQ case assistant, advanced document automation, split billing, and Open API.

Across every tier, MyCase is $30 or more per seat per month cheaper than CasePeer’s equivalent tier, and MyCase additionally offers an annual discount that CasePeer does not publish.

When to pick CasePeer

CasePeer is purpose-built for personal injury firms. The Basic tier already includes features that a PI firm would otherwise need to assemble: automated statute-of-limitations alerts, settlement negotiation tracking, medical treatment tracking, case expense tracking, and client trust tracking. The Pro tier adds PI-relevant reporting, a High Value Cases report, Medical Requests report, and Firm Productivity report, plus litigation event plans.

CasePeer targets small and mid-size firms rather than solos, which aligns with PI firms that typically have intake staff, paralegals, and multiple attorneys working a shared caseload. The Advanced tier’s intake investigator portal, case grades, multi-office reporting suite, and API access are features oriented at mid-size PI operations that need to measure pipeline quality and integrate with other systems.

If your firm does PI work and wants a vertical tool rather than a horizontal platform you have to configure, CasePeer’s feature list maps more directly to the work.

When to pick MyCase

MyCase is priced and scoped for solos and small general-practice firms. At $49/month (or $39 annual) per seat, Basic is accessible to a solo practitioner, and every tier is cheaper than CasePeer’s equivalent tier. MyCase explicitly targets general practice rather than a single vertical, so firms that handle a mix of practice areas, family, estate, employment, small business, transactional, won’t be paying for PI-specific workflows they don’t use.

MyCase also bakes billing and online payments into the Basic tier, along with time entry, expense tracking, and basic financial reporting. For firms that bill hourly or on flat fees (rather than contingency), that matters, CasePeer’s published tier features don’t emphasize time-and-billing the same way. The Advanced tier adds MyCase Drive, full text search, advanced document automation, split billing, and Open API at $119/month, which is the same price as CasePeer’s Basic tier.

If you’re a solo or small general-practice firm that needs case management plus billing in one tool at a predictable low price, MyCase fits more naturally.

Integrations and ecosystem

Neither vendor’s JSON lists specific integration partners, so a direct count isn’t possible from the data provided. However, both reference integrations in their tier descriptions:

• CasePeer Pro tier advertises “20+ Key Integrations” and the Advanced tier adds API access.
• MyCase Pro tier advertises Google, Outlook, ”+ more,” and the Advanced tier includes Open API.

Both platforms therefore expose an API at their top tier and advertise third-party integrations at the middle tier. Firms that require a specific named integration should verify directly with each vendor, since neither JSON provides a concrete list.

Historical pricing context

CasePeer’s published starting price has held steady at $79/month across seven Wayback snapshots from July 2024 through January 2026, no observed increase over roughly 18 months of captures.

MyCase’s history is thinner in the provided data: a January 2022 snapshot at $49/month and a March 2022 snapshot at $39/month under a “Basic” label. The current published rate is $49/month ($39 with annual commitment), which is consistent with the 2022 range. Both vendors have shown pricing stability in their starter tiers over the captured windows, with CasePeer’s data being the more robust trajectory.

Citations

Pricing sourced from vendor pricing pages on 2026-04-24. Historical data from Wayback Machine.